Should I Sign Up For Overdraft Protection?

A: Overdraft protection can keep your account from landing in the red, but there can be some disadvantages to this service as well. Let’s take a closer look at this popular checking account feature so you can make an informed decision before signing up.

What is overdraft protection?

Overdraft protection is a service offered by banks and credit unions that allows you to complete transactions even when you don’t have sufficient funds in your account. When you sign up for overdraft protection, the financial institution covers the shortfall, typically through linking to another account (like a savings or a line of credit), or by extending automatic coverage. While this can prevent the immediate headache of a declined transaction, it may come with hefty fees and/or interest rates.

The cost of convenience

The primary appeal of overdraft protection is convenience. It ensures that your transactions go through smoothly, sparing you potential embarrassment at checkout or the hassle of dealing with unpaid bills. However, this convenience comes at a price. Many banks and some credit unions charge an overdraft fee each time the service is used, which can range from $30 to $40 per transaction. This means if you make multiple small purchases while your account is overdrawn, you could be hit with several fees, which quickly add up to a significant amount. To add insult to injury, unless you check your account balance, you won’t know it’s overdrawn and transactions may get represented a time or two, incurring additional fees. [Here at Pinal County Federal Credit Union, we are proud to offer overdraft protection for our members without any/for the minimal fee of $30/overdrawn transaction.]

The hidden trap of fees

What makes overdraft protection particularly insidious is how quickly the fees can accumulate. For example, if you buy a $4 coffee and your account is overdrawn, you could be charged a $35 overdraft fee, effectively paying $39 for that coffee! If you continue making small purchases, you could incur multiple fees before you realize there’s an issue. Some banks even charge an additional fee for each day your account remains overdrawn, exacerbating the financial strain.

Encouraging poor financial habits

Overdraft protection can encourage poor financial habits by providing a false sense of security. When you know your purchases will be covered, you may be less vigilant about monitoring your account balance and managing your finances carefully. This can lead to a cycle of dependency on overdraft protection, where you repeatedly incur fees and struggle to regain financial control.

The hidden trap of fees

What makes overdraft protection particularly insidious is how quickly the fees can accumulate. For example, if you buy a $4 coffee and your account is overdrawn, you could be charged a $35 overdraft fee, effectively paying $39 for that coffee! If you continue making small purchases, you could incur multiple fees before you realize there’s an issue. Some banks even charge an additional fee for each day your account remains overdrawn, exacerbating the financial strain.

Encouraging poor financial habits

Overdraft protection can encourage poor financial habits by providing a false sense of security. When you know your purchases will be covered, you may be less vigilant about monitoring your account balance and managing your finances carefully. This can lead to a cycle of dependency on overdraft protection, where you repeatedly incur fees and struggle to regain financial control.

Should I choose overdraft protection?

Overdraft protection may be a good option for you if your financial institution offers the service with no or minimal fees. However, you may want to institute the following practices to ensure you rarely use this feature:

1. Set up low balance alerts. Many banks and credit unions offer alerts that notify you when your account balance falls below a certain threshold. Setting up these alerts can help you stay aware of your balance to avoid accidental overdrafts.
2. Link to a savings account. Instead of relying on overdraft protection, consider linking your checking account to a savings account or personal line of credit. This way, funds can be transferred automatically to cover shortfalls, and often with lower or no fees compared to traditional overdraft protection.
3. Keep a buffer in your checking account. Maintain a financial buffer in your checking account. Keeping an extra $100 or $200 in your account can act as a cushion, thus reducing the likelihood of overdrafts.
4. Use budgeting tools. Utilize budgeting apps and tools to monitor your spending and ensure you have enough funds to cover your transactions. These tools can help you manage your money more effectively and avoid overdrawing your account.

Overdraft protection is often marketed as a convenient solution to avoid the embarrassment and inconvenience of declined transactions. However, it can be a costly trap, leading to significant fees and encouraging poor financial habits. Use our guide to learn all about overdraft protection and how to use it effectively when warranted.

« Return to "News, Blogs & More" Go to main navigation